Sugar pie (sometimes called sugar cream pie) tastes like crème brûlée in pie format. It’s rich and decadent and the filling requires just six ingredients – sugar, butter, half and half, vanilla, nutmeg, and cornstarch.
People go crazy for my sugar pie and it’s so simple to make. Plus, it uses simple ingredients that you may already have on hand.
If you haven’t heard of this pie, you are not alone. It’s most common in Indiana and has been popularized by the Amish. When I served it to my friends in St. Louis, none of them had tried it before.
Tasting its rich, caramel-like flavor, you might assume that it is loaded with eggs like a traditional custard – but it’s the cornstarch that gives sugar pie its custard-like texture.
There are no eggs in this recipe.
How to Make Sugar Pie
One of the nice things about this pie is that it is a one saucepan recipe. You don’t need to mess with lots of mixing bowls.
First, melt butter in a saucepan.
Then, mix in all of the other ingredients except for the vanilla and stir for about five minutes. As you stir, the cornstarch will thicken the mixture until it becomes porridge-like.
Once it reaches that consistency, you can stir in the vanilla.
Sugar Pie Crust
Sugar pie typically uses classic butter crust like this pie crust from BraveTart.
However, for a variation, I like to use a shortbread crust and only put it on the bottom, not up the sides of the pan.
Sugar pie will hold its shape so it doesn’t need side crust to keep it from collapsing. Shortbread crust is easy to make and when you use shortbread crust, you automatically get a cookie with your pie!
I especially like using shortbread crust when I make this pie in a skillet.
I love serving this pie in small cast iron skillets. The skillets make for a rustic presentation and a group of four can just dig in with forks!
You can also bake it in an 8″ square pan with a shortbread crust and cut rectangular slices.
There has been some debate in the comments on this post as to what true sugar pie is. It turns out that there are many different versions and there is no right or wrong one. There is a maple sugar pie (popular in Canada) and a brown sugar pie. Some are thickened with flour and some use corn starch. The recipe below is adapted from AllRecipes and is a winner and a great place to start your sugar pie baking exploration.
For some other variations, try my chocolate sugar pie is always a big hit! It’s a similar recipe, but with super chocolaty filling and crust.
You could make a coffee-flavored sugar pie by steeping the half and half with coffee beans like I show in my post on baking with coffee.
You could also add lemon or orange zest or spices like cinnamon and nutmeg for something more fall- or winter-themed.
I also love the idea that someone mentioned in the comments of adding peaches to make a peaches and cream pie!
When to Serve
I’m a sucker for cheesy, romantic plans and I love the idea of serving this to my sugar pie on Valentine’s Day. But, in truth, there is never a bad time!
Skillet Sugar Pie
Shortbread Crust Ingredients
- 3 tablespoons unsalted butter room temperature
- 6 tablespoons granulated sugar
- 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
- 6 tablespoons rolled oats
- 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
Sugar Pie Filling Ingredients
- 4 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 4 tablespoons cornstarch
- 3/4 cup granulated sugar
- 2 1/4 cups half and half
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1/2 teaspoon freshly ground nutmeg
Shortbread Crust Instructions
- Mix all shortbread crust ingredients by hand in a small mixing bowl until they just begin to stick together.
- Grease a 9" pie pan and press shortbread crust into the bottom of the pan.
Sugar Pie Filling Instructions
- In a medium-sized saucepan, melt butter on medium heat.
- Once butter is melted, whisk in cornstarch and sugar.
- Slowly whisk in the half and half.
- Stir constantly until the mixture begins to boil and becomes thick and creamy. This should take about five minutes. You'll know it's ready as there will be a dramatic shift from a soupy liquid to something porridge-like.
- Remove from heat and mix in vanilla. (If there are any lumps, you can push the filling through a sieve to remove them.)
Assembly and Baking Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350 F.
- Place prepared pie pan on a cookie sheet (in case of any overflow during baking). Distribute filling evenly over shortbread in the prepared pan. Because pie pan depths may vary, keep in mind that this filling is supposed to come almost up to the top of the pie.
- Sprinkle nutmeg over the filling.
- Bake for 70 minutes or until the top of the pie is set and the top is somewhat browned. The filling will still be a little jiggly, but it won't move very much if you wiggle the pie. If it doesn't seem set yet, continue to cook a little longer. It's better to over-bake this pie than to under-bake it.
- Remove from the oven and cool to room temperature.
- Refrigerate overnight and serve cold.