5 Reasons to Ditch Eggnog and Choose Syllabub | Cupcake Project
Home  »  Recipes  »  Drinks  »  5 Reasons to Ditch Eggnog and Choose Syllabub

5 Reasons to Ditch Eggnog and Choose Syllabub


I am going to go out there and say that syllabub is better than eggnog. I know you are going to call me on the whole personal preference thing. We all have different taste buds, blah, blah, blah. Well, bah humbug! Here are five definitive reasons you should be making syllabub this holiday season:

  1. The recipe for syllabub as it was originally written calls for a mix of hard cider, milk, cream, and nutmeg, sweetened with a little sugar. I love it with the cider – syllabub tastes like a cross between an apple cream pie and eggnog.  However, you can make syllabub with any alcohol – many people use wine and some lemon. You have options! Take that, rum-only eggnog!
  2. No eggs! While some syllabub recipes do call for eggs, they are by no means a requirement. Not having to deal with eggs while still achieving a frothy, boozy drink is a huge win.
  3. Syllabub is likely what Alexander Hamilton would have been drinking on Christmas. (See that whole story by my contributor, Jess Touchette, below.) If you have any musical buffs coming to your Christmas celebration, this drink is a must!
  4. Syllabubs were traditionally served in their own special type of glassware – wide at the top to hold the cream and narrower at the bottom (see Food History Jottings for a nice example). You can find the glassware at antique shops and give the recipe and a couple of glasses as a totally unique holiday gift. The glass that we used in the photo isn’t quite a syllabub glass, but it works. Feel free to get a little creative.
  5. Syllabub is simply a fun word to say. (True, nog is a fun word to say, too, but it’s overplayed.)

Now that we’ve gotten that out of the way and you fully comprehend how much I love this drink, let’s move on to Jessica’s post for a fascinating Hamiltonian history and the syllabub recipe!

With a hit Broadway musical bearing his name, Alexander Hamilton – America’s “ten-dollar founding father without a father” – is making a comeback. From his too-short childhood in his single mother’s Caribbean shop to his violent death in a duel with Aaron Burr, Hamilton managed to fit a whole lot of life into only 47 years. He was (among other things) an orphan, a war hero, a father of eight, the first U.S. Secretary of the Treasury, a failed presidential candidate, the primary writer of The Federalist Papers, and the founder of the U.S. Mint, and there are all sorts of questions that we could reasonably ask about his life. So, let’s go with what is clearly most pressing: what did the guy like to eat?

Unfortunately, it turns out that there is little-to-no concrete information about what Alexander Hamilton ate. Between his correspondence and his political writings, Hamilton left behind hundreds of pages of evidence about his life and his thoughts, but not one casual mention (at least that I could find) of the fabulous dish that his wife Eliza ordered for dinner the Wednesday before. This certainly doesn’t stop us from speculating about what Hamilton may have eaten throughout his life. From records of his mother’s store in St. Croix, for example, we might gather that his diet in early childhood was simple but plentiful. The store carried salted fish and pork, beef, apples, butter, rice, and flour, and his mother kept her own milk goat. A National Park Service report on the furnishings of the Grange (Alexander and Elizabeth Hamilton’s home in Manhattan) implies that Hamilton’s adult diet was more refined. The report, which includes selected entries from his cash books, shows that he spent $15.75 on “Muffins” in February 1798, $500.00 on a silver tea and coffee set in March 1798, and, between 1798 and 1803, over $460.00 on wine and port. These expenditures imply that the Hamiltons were keeping up with the dining fashions of the well-to-do, but reveal very little beyond that.

Even the meal featured in “The Room Where it Happens” – scene of the legendary June 20, 1790 Dinner Table Bargain hammered out by Hamilton, James Madison, and host Thomas Jefferson – is a mystery. In Dinner at Mr. Jefferson’s, popular historian Charles A. Cerami goes so far as to lay out a possible menu for the evening, including only dishes known to have been served by Jefferson during his career. Yet while the dishes outlined in Cerami’s book are tantalizing (who wouldn’t marvel at vanilla ice cream encased in warm pastry?), there is no concrete evidence of what Hamilton ate even then, during what has arguably become the most talked-about (and romanticized) meal of his life.

Since Hamilton’s food preferences seem to have been well and truly lost to time, I decided to consult an early American cookbook and indulge in my own bit of speculation about what our founding father would have eaten. For this, I turned to the first cookbook published in America by an American author: Amelia Simmons’ 1796 American Cookery.

Simmons’ cookbook contains a guide to selecting produce, recipes for classic English dishes (such as roast beef and pound cake), and distinctly American recipes featuring ingredients indigenous to North American (such as cornmeal-based “Indian Pudding”). Her sizable selection of dessert recipes includes all of the usual suspects – puddings, cookies, cakes, pies, tarts, and preserves – but also a category you may be less familiar with: “Syllabubs.”

Syllabub is a drink made from sweetened cream, alcohol, and sometimes eggs. It can be served beaten smooth or whipped (as, essentially, whipped cream floating on alcohol). Similar in flavor to eggnog, though typified by a frothy rather than a smooth texture, syllabub was all the rage in the 18th century. It’s almost certain that Hamilton would have enjoyed this decadent drink, likely served cold in a globed glass to accentuate the separation of the alcohol from the cream.

If you’d like to give this whippy (and tipsy) beverage a try, I’ve included an adapted version of Amelia Simmons’ recipe for “fine syllabub” below. Simmons instructs you to milk your cow directly into a tub of sweetened cyder to create the ultimate froth, but for those of you without a milk cow on hand, a whisk should work just as well.

Join the free mailing list to receive the latest recipes, tips, and tricks by email!
Print Pin
5 from 2 votes

Syllabub Recipe

Syllabub is a hard cider recipe perfect for Christmas.
Course Drinks
Cuisine American
Keyword syllabub, syllabub recipe
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Servings 6 servings
Calories 123kcal


  • 1 cup hard cider
  • 1/4 cup granulated sugar use more or less to taste
  • 1/4 cup whole milk room temperature
  • 1/2 teaspoon nutmeg plus more for serving
  • 1/2 cup cream


  • In a medium-sized bowl, add the sugar to the cider and whisk until dissolved.
  • Stir in milk and nutmeg.
  • Add cream and whisk until a thickened, foamy layer of cream forms on top of the mixture.
  • Spoon the layer of cream into a small bowl and set aside.
  • Pour the remaining cider/milk mixture into serving glasses, filling the glasses no more than three-quarters of the way full.
  • Top each glass with a dollop of the cream topping.
  • Sprinkle with nutmeg and serve.


adapted from Amelia Simmons’ Syllabub (1796)


Nutrition Facts
Syllabub Recipe
Amount Per Serving
Calories 123 Calories from Fat 63
% Daily Value*
Fat 7g11%
Saturated Fat 4g20%
Cholesterol 28mg9%
Sodium 13mg1%
Potassium 28mg1%
Carbohydrates 10g3%
Sugar 9g10%
Vitamin A 310IU6%
Calcium 24mg2%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Have you tried this recipe?Click here to leave a comment and rating!


Simmons, Amelia. American Cookery: Or the Art of Dressing Viands, Fish, Poultry and Vegetables, and the Best Modes of Making Pastes, Puffs, Pies, Tarts, Puddings, Custards and Preserves, and All Kinds of Cakes, from the Imperial Plumb to Plain Cake. Hartford: Printed by Hudson & Goodwin, 1796.

“To make a fine Syllabub from the Cow.

Sweeten a quart of cyder with double refined sugar, grate nutmeg into it, then milk your cow directly into your liquor, when you have thus added what quantity of milk you think proper, pour half a pint or more, in proportion to the quantity of syllabub you make, of the sweetest cream you can get all over it” (31).

Jessica Touchette

Jess Touchette is a special collections librarian living in St. Louis, Missouri. A food history enthusiast and an amateur baker, she enjoys poring over centuries-old recipes and attempting to bring them new life in a modern kitchen.
Love it? Share it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

4 comments on “5 Reasons to Ditch Eggnog and Choose Syllabub”

  1. Nancy Pollacksays:

    When are you making it? Sounds like one could happily drink more than one. > would certainly try

  2. Serenasays:

    So, so fascinating – love historical recipes that actually work! I’m a retro glassware hoarder. But I need to find syllabub glasses now. I will definitely be serving this weekend…yay to no raw egg issues!

  3. Mirandasays:

    I’ve never dried syllabub but now I need to try it! It sounds like something I would love!

  4. Diane Wrightsays:

    I’m so glad I have discovered the syllabub! Can’t wait to make one in the spring, when my home made cider has aged and my goat is in milk. Have you tried it with goats milk??

Show All Comments

Stay Connected!

Join my mailing list - and receive a free eBook!

Sign me up!
Gray Logos Representing Media Where Cupcake Project has Appeared
Next Post