Cookie Dough That's Safe to Eat ~ Cupcake Project

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Cookie Dough That's Safe to Eat

StumbleUpon Stumble This Post

Cookie dough makes me feel like a messy girl with pigtails, beaters, and a big grin - all over again! I love cupcake batter, but cookie dough is in a class of its own. Sadly, it's probably not the safest idea for me to down gobs of raw cookie dough containing raw egg in my pregnant state (although - there is some debate about the dangers of raw egg).

The good news is that making cookie dough that is egg-free and totally safe to eat is incredibly easy. Because you aren't going to be baking the cookie dough, you don't need to worry at all about getting proportions just right, sifting, or the order of incorporating ingredients into the dough. You just dump all the ingredients in a bowl, mix, and you're done.

What to Do With Raw Cookie Dough

There are countless things to do with raw cookie dough. Some ideas are:

  • Mix it with vanilla ice cream for your own homemade cookie dough ice cream.
  • Swirl it in with fudge for some cookie dough fudge.
  • Spread a layer of it in between two cakes instead of frosting. This would be awesome with cheesecake.
  • Just leave it sitting around with a spoon and eat some periodically.
  • Make cookie dough cupcakes.
Raw Cookie Dough Recipe

I used the recipe for my cacao nib cookies as a base for the raw cookie dough recipe. To make it egg-less, I used milk to replace the moisture from the eggs. It worked perfectly!
  • 2 C all-purpose flour
  • 1/2 t salt
  • 3/4 C unsalted butter, melted
  • 1 C packed brown sugar
  • 1/2 C white sugar
  • 1 T vanilla extract
  • 4 T milk
  • Any amount of any mix-in you'd like - I used cacao nibs, but chocolate chips, nuts, or fruit would all work.
  1. Mix all ingredients in a big bowl. That's it!

44 comments:

Becky said...

Delish! Who wants raw egg anyway?! Thighs, say hello to your new nemesis.

Elyse said...

How wonderful! I love your idea about spreading a layer between two cakes!! That sounds absolutely fabulous.

Eliana said...

I would have never thought about spreading it between layers of a cake instead of frosting. BRILLIANT! Now then what would you use to frost the outside of the cake?

Knot By Gran'ma said...

Best blog post ever! Thank you for sharing.

Ivy said...

Oh no, this is waaay too dangerous for me. ca-nnn-ottt loooooookk at recipe.ERKK! :)

Stef said...

Eliana - You'd frost with cookie dough frosting of course. The recipe will be in my next post!

A. Fiercehair said...

My roommate loves raw cookie dough; perhaps I'll try your leave-it-out-with-a-spoon-in-it trick. :)

thereddeer said...

Australians don't have the same obsession with cookie dough....yet! Sounds yummy though, I am going to bookmark this for future reference. Thanks!

Jen H said...

Yummy!!! My office will love these!

veggievixen said...

that's why i love vegan cookie dough!!

Jason said...

Stef, I'm thinking somewhere along the lines of what's in this link:

http://www.recipezaar.com/Low-Fat-Vegan-Cookie-Dough-346438

Although when I make it at some point in the future, it will be even healthier than that.

As long as I'm going to be eating pounds of raw cookie dough at a time, I figure it should be somewhat healthy :)

ourlifeinfood said...

This looks fantastic! What a great recipe!

Gourmet Mama said...

Oh, I am so making this for my kids. They always want to eat cookie dough and since I`ve had salmonella, I don`t let them. This is perfect!

stephchows said...

LOL Awesome!!! I used to make batches of cookie dough minus the eggs with friends growing up. Then we would chow the whole batch raw!

anna said...

I've made eggless cookie dough before! I made a batch and rolled it into balls and froze them as a treat for my boyfriend. I'm totally going to make some homemade cookie dough ice cream this summer, ice cream maker or no.

aubrey said...

genius. This recipe will come in handy. Thanks for sharing!

Sara said...

Oh yum- I'm loving your cheesecake idea, how good would that be?! I'm definitely going to be thinking of a great way to use this stuff!

Meg Baxter said...

Thank you! I'm 17 weeks preggo and have also lamented over my inability to partake in the my usual cookie dough-eating rituals. :) This is a recipe I'll be sure to try.

☾ Ash ♡ said...

Mmmmmm.. somehow I missed along the way you're Preggers.. CONGRATS!! Being a mom is the best thing Ever! (and I have a 13 year old boy.. still, he's the best!)

This looks like it might be sitting in a tub in the fridge (where the kid won't find it)as a base for Cheesecake for Easter.. Hmm.. YUMMY!!

Hillary said...

Thanks for the recipe and ideas! I must confess I eat the raw cookie dough I'm NOT supposed to eat...same goes with cake batter, eep!

Hayley said...

This is the best! I usually just eat the raw stuff anyways, but now I won't feel so bad. Thanks for sharing!

finsmom said...

Isnt this just perfect for a lazy day! Makes me want to eat some while relaxing on the couch!

Thanks for sharing! Yum!

eatyet said...

my cousin told me that some flour might be contaminated by salmonenella. http://www.ecolab.com/PublicHealth/Salmonella.asp

Shelly said...

This is great! I totally pig out on the stuff w/ eggs but wonder if/when I'll end up getting sick. Well, now I won't have to!

Anonymous said...

i just tried this tonight and it was sooo good!! i just found out i'm pregnant and still don't know what to eat/what not to eat, but i had a taste for cookie dough and i tried this egg free kind and it's super wicked good!!!

pearls and polaroids said...

oh my gosh this is soooo nice, i'm so bad at cooking i burn cookies and make cupcakes sink but this was so easy i could do it!

Anonymous said...

haa, i tried this but i accidentally used waay too much salt. it would have been really good if i didnt though [: i'll be trying again soon!

Alice said...

Best recipe ever taste, and believe that wasn't my first time ;) Thank you !

Anonymous said...

Use Unsalted butter! I made this and it was so salty. I should've listened. THe flavor was nearly there though

Kimberley said...

Thankyou sooo much!
Im looking forward to making this today.
This is the only good recepie for cookie dough I have found.
Thanks.
Cant wait to pig out on it. =]

Anonymous said...

so gross!, that's how you get fat when pregnant! feed your babe something more nutricious darling and did you know there chocolate at the store? duh!

Anonymous said...

oh darling! take it easy! eat some fruit and veggies for your sake! or you're gonna be with antidepresants after that baby comes!.

Anonymous said...

gee! theres so much sweets at the store, why do you have to eat THAT!
HELLO CELLULITE?

Anonymous said...

I BET IT TASTE GOOD FOR YOU TONGE BUT YOUR BODY CRIES INSIDE OF YOU AFTER EATING THIS.
I RATHER HAVE A BODY LIKE CINDY MCKANE THAN MARTHA STEWART WHEN I TURN 40!

Eve said...

What the heck is wrong with the post prior to mine ??? I think this recipe is awesome.... =) I'm going to use it today for my holiday cookies Yummy !!!

Thx for sharing darling !!! =)

Tina said...

ThaT AnonymouS PosteR MusT Be An Idiot.

KeeP ThE GooD WorK! YouR RecipE Is MarvelouS


TinA BrighT

Hannah said...

Could these be made into regular cookies without adding eggs?

Nala said...

ok so this recipe is great and all but did i do something wrong? did it say add one TABLESPOON od TEASPOON of vanilla extract cuz i used a tablespoon and all i could tatse was vanilla someone help me........!

Stef said...

Hannah - No, you would need to add eggs.

Nala - I used a tablespoon. You can reduce it if it is too vanilla-y for you.

Nala said...

Stef - Did they tast giid? thanks

M. said...

I LOVE this! Me and my Friend AShley are sitting here eating it plain Right now! We are 13 and 14 and did it ourself! haha. (: Thanks for posting this!(:

Stef said...

M. - Glad you guys are enjoying!

Stef said...

Nala - Yes. It tasted good.

Nala said...

Stef - Ha ok im gunna try the recipe again and see what i did wrong. Thanks