Babka pie grows organically in the oven, climbing up and over the edge of the pie pan. You can’t contain its greatness in a neat and tidy package. Inside, you’ll find sweet, yeasty bread with flowing swirls of chocolate and a gooey blend of nuts and more chocolate (this time, chips). The filling sometimes finds its way to the bottom of the pie and sometimes prefers to rest on the bread pillow at the top. Babka pie is a pie you can eat with your hands, tearing at the layers like a cinnamon roll, and you’ll need to lick your chocolaty fingers clean after your last bite. If you must, you can use a fork to tame the wildness.
Babka is popular at bakeries in NY and you might remember it from this classic episode of Seinfeld:
The kooky idea of turning babka into a pie was all mine. I used Peter Reinhart’s babka recipe from Craftsy’s Artisan Bread Baking course for the “crust” of the pie. You can get the recipe from the course (I’d highly suggest that) or use any other babka recipe that you may have. Then, I filled the crust with a Derby Pie-like filling of walnuts and chocolate chips with lots of sugar and butter. Instead of Derby Pie’s bourbon, I used a splash of orange juice. Here’s what babka pie looks like before it enters the oven:
Babka Pie Crust Ingredients
- See the recipe in Peter Reinhart's Craftsy class or use the ingredients for any other chocolate babka recipe that you like.
Pie Filling Ingredients
- 1/2 cup unsalted butter melted
- 3/4 cup brown sugar
- 1/4 cup sugar
- 1/4 cup golden syrup or light corn syrup
- 4 large large eggs
- 1/4 cup orange juice
- 1 1/4 cups chopped walnuts
- 3/4 cup dark chocolate chips
- Follow the instructions for your babka recipe through the point when the babka is rolled into a log with the chocolate filling.
Pie Filling Instructions
- In a medium-sized mixing bowl, whisk together all ingredients except nuts and chips.
- Fold in nuts and chips.
Babka Pie Assembly Instructions
- Preheat oven to 325 F.
- Stretch the log to about 18" and twist it a couple of times (as you would do if you were wringing out a wet t-shirt) to add more chocolate swirls.
- Cut the log into three sections. Things were a little messy for me at this point, but it worked just fine.
- Press the ends of each log to seal them closed. Roll each log out to a near circle that fits in a 5" pie pan. The chocolate surprisingly stays in the log pretty well at this point since it will have hardened.
- Transfer the rolled babka dough to the pie pans - keep in mind that the babka will grow a lot in the oven. If you don't want the edges to be way over the sides of the pie pans, keep them low in the pan in this step.
- Divide the pie filling evenly between the pies.
- Bake pies on cookie sheets (just in case they overflow a little) for 50 minutes.